The Myth of “Permanent” Resident Status

A new Green Card is in many ways like a new car. It looks shiny, smells freshly manufactured, and signals newfound mobility.

 

However, Permanent Residency is a misleading term. The Green Card is in fact only a symbol of a person’s status as a Lawful Permanent Resident (“LPR”) of the United States. It is the obligation of every LPR to maintain this status. If the status is not maintained, then it may be considered “abandoned.” Below are a couple of the most common misconceptions about Permanent Residency.

 

Myth 1: The card is what matters. As long as a person possesses an unexpired Green Card, he or she is an LPR of the United States, and can travel freely to and from the US.

 

This myth is false, and relying upon it can lead to serious and expensive consequences. This is especially important for Green Card holders residing outside the United States. US passport holders can leave the US, live abroad for a few years, and return as they please. But the Green Card is not equivalent to a US passport. Green Card holders are strictly limited in terms of how much time they can spend outside the US before they must return. If they do not abide by the rules, they can lose their Green Card, even if the card is still within its validity dates. Put another way, the card is not what matters. Rather, the status that the card represents is what matters.

 

Now we know that it is the Green Card holder’s responsibility to preserve his or her LPR status. How does one go about doing this? There are misconceptions regarding this too. Below is a common one.

 

Myth 2: Visiting the US every six months ensures that your Green Card will remain valid until its expiration date.

 

Not so!

 

This myth likely originates from the rules surrounding long stays of LPRs outside of the US. It is true that Green Card holders are subject to enhanced scrutiny if they remain outside the US for periods longer than six months. But this does not mean that absences shorter than six months avoid any scrutiny.

 

How do LPRs maintain their status? The general rule is that Green Card holders must live in the US. For Green Card holders who need to be outside the US for long periods of time, a Re-Entry Permit will help show that they have not abandoned their status. Re-entry Permits are a useful tool for preserving LPR status, and for avoiding the much more time-consuming and costly option of the Returning Resident (SB-1) Visa.

 

It is tragic when someone invests time, energy, and money to obtain a Green Card, only to have it invalidated because of “abandonment” due to long absences from the US. As with most avoidable legal disasters, the best preventative measure is discussing your specific situation with an experienced attorney as early in the process as possible. This is the best way to ensure your Green Card remains the tool for mobility it was designed to be.

 

 

All said and explained in this article does not constitute a legal opinion and does not replace legal advice. Responsibility for using the wordings and opinions conveyed in this article relies solely and entirely on the reader.

This article was written by Dotan Cohen Law Offices, working in the field of immigration law in the United States, Canada, Australia and England.

Israel

“I’m very grateful to you for the professional and quick handling my case in receiving the Green Card in a very short time !!”
Amnon Karmi
Family Based Green Card
March 31st, 2018
“I would like to thank you for your great professional work. The papers whom I carried to the interview were impressive and I felt confident that this process will be approved for sure. Best, Ronen Rick”
Ronen Rick
E-1 Work Visa
March 2nd, 2017
DC LAW OFFICES לכבוד משרד עורכי דין אני מבקש להודות לכם על הליווי המדהים שלכם בתהליך קבלת הגרין קארד. הייתם מצויינים. הרגשתי שהיה לי על מי לסמוך בכל נושא לאורך הדרך, איסוף הנתונים, הכנת התיק לשגרירות, לראיון האישי וההתמודדות עם גורמי ראשויות החוק האמריקאים. הייעוץ והיחס היה חם לכל אורך הדרך. המענה שלכם לכל בקשה שלי היה מהיר ועינייני. לכל מי שמצויי בתהליך בקשת גרין קארד או כל התנהלות מול ממשלת ארצות הברית (או ממשלה אחרת) אמליץ בחום על משרד עורכי הדין שלכם. תודה רבה, ד“ר בעז מזרחי
Boaz Mizrahi
DV-2014
March 18 2015
DC LAW OFFICES לכבוד משרד עורכי דין אני מבקש להודות לכם על הליווי המדהים שלכם בתהליך קבלת הגרין קארד. הייתם מצויינים. הרגשתי שהיה לי על מי לסמוך בכל נושא לאורך הדרך, איסוף הנתונים, הכנת התיק לשגרירות, לראיון האישי וההתמודדות עם גורמי ראשויות החוק האמריקאים. הייעוץ והיחס היה חם לכל אורך הדרך. המענה שלכם לכל בקשה שלי היה מהיר ועינייני. לכל מי שמצויי בתהליך בקשת גרין קארד או כל התנהלות מול ממשלת ארצות הברית (או ממשלה אחרת) אמליץ בחום על משרד עורכי הדין שלכם. תודה רבה, ד“ר בעז מזרחי
Boaz Mizrahi
DV-2014
March 18 2015
“This letter is our personal recommendation for Dotan Cohen, Law Offices. In the last year they took care of our Green Card application. We found Dotan and his team very cooperative and very helpful they are professional, we got very detailed answers to our concerns and primarily they are consistently pleasant to work with. We defiantly can say that without the escort we got from Dotan and his team throughout the application process we would never got our Green Card. From our experience we would like to recommend to all the GC applicants if you really want to be a green card holders do not save the cost of a lawyer and hire Dotan Cohen, Law Offices.” Amit M./ DV-2009/ July 28th 2009/ Israel “Thanks very much for your help with my application. The interview was successful and everything ran very smoothly. Your input was very valuable, both while filling the forms and while preparing for the interview. You were thorough, responsive to my many questions, and most importantly, supportive. Thanks again,”
Shaul & Esty S.
DV-2009
November 23rd 2009
“I would like to thank the staff at Dotan Cohen Offices for all their efforts in assisting me to achieve my Green Card. In my case, I needed help in defining my occupation so that I can get my Green Card. If it wasn’t for the experienced lawyers at Dotan Cohen Law Offices, I would not have received my Green Card.”
Yossi C.
DV-2008
August 31st 2008
Bantsi Gafni
Shira Gafni
Another satisfied customer! Shira received American citizenship

I only have a question